Style2

Lili (1953) Directed by Charles Walters





(Review originally written at 28 November 2008)

I didn't know what to expect from this movie in advance but as it turned out it was a very charming little movie, that has a sweet naive little main character and a cute original love-story.

The movie begins as a formulaic one in which a girl meets a boy and basically immediately falls in love with him. However when the movie starts to progress more it becomes obvious that the movie is not taking the most obvious and expected path. About halve way through the movie makes a turn, which makes the overall approach of the movie and its story quite original, especially for the '50's usual genre standards.

The movie is perhaps at time being told as a modern fairytale. I think this was done to show the story from the eyes of the young main character, who is a bit of a naive girl still. Amazing thing about the movie its main love story is that the main character falls in love with a man not thanks to his charm but through the puppets he plays. Sounds really wrong and cheesy but in the movie itself it works out surprisingly well and effective. The man is not that good at showing his true feelings and emotions and uses his different puppets as an outlet of his emotions and to show the girl in his own way he cares about her. The girl, naive as she is, doesn't really see the man behind the puppets but starts to believe in her own mind that the puppets are real and her only true friends in life. No matter how bad I'm probably making it sounds right now, it works out really well and charming for the movie.

There is something else odd about this movie. The entire movie is set indoors and at the same locations but yet the movie has such a sense of freedom and freshness, as if its set in an open field, with hills with flowers on it. This is probably more to the fairytale approach of the story that gives the movie this feeling and overall atmosphere.

It all makes "Lili" such a perfectly light and enjoyable movie to watch. Yes, it in a way also sort of makes this a redundant one, I mean this movie by no means is a true essential viewing and easily one you could do without. But when you do decide to watch you'll be perfectly entertained by it all and grabbed by the movie its charm. This movie also must had been a real surprise at its own time. It's a fairly low budget movie and without any big names in it, or behind the camera's but yet the movie earned a total of 6 Oscar nominations and not in the least categories. It only won one though, for its music.

It's also of course thanks to the movie its cast that the movie works out that way. The actors all play their characters in a charming, though yet very formulaic way but without ever feeling over-the-top and not very likely.

Really charming 'modern' fairytale.

8/10

Watch trailer

Columbo: Requiem for a Falling Star (1973) Directed by Richard Quine





(Review originally written at 8 May 2008)

The movie is directed by Richard Quine, who simply isn't among one of the most talented directors who ever worked on a Columbo movie. Despite this he directed a total of 3 Columbo movies, so he must have done something right in the mind of the creators and studio bosses or he must have had friends in right places. To me it seemed that he didn't really understood the Columbo character right and often overdid things involving the famous character, mostly with his intelligence and perception of things. He also in some ways differ from the usual Columbo formula, which just isn't always for the good.

It isn't among the fastest going or best flowing Columbo movies but this is mostly being compensated by the acting and scenes with Anne Baxter and Kevin McCarthy. Both of them are a bit of forgotten stars, who also never reached true stardom but did their share of good movies and played some fine roles. It's mostly their movie, which also sort of means that Peter Falk is playing third violin in this one. This especially shows in the sequences when the three of them are together on screen. Another indication of that Richard Quine didn't really knew how to handle the character right (His car also looks dirtier than ever before by the way).

It features a good and quite non-formulaic Columbo murder-mystery story that however due to its treatment and pace just never really gets of the ground. Some minor script changes and a different director at the helm could had made this a true great and original Columbo movie entry! It features a story that is set in the world of Hollywood and movie-making and therefor also features some good egocentric characters who think they own the world and can get away with anything, even murder.

No it's really not one of the worst Columbo movies out there and it simply is just a bit below the usual Columbo movie standard in the long run and it's also definitely a big step up from Richard Quine's other Columbo movie "Columbo: Dagger of the Mind" but it still leaves you with the feeling that it all could had been done better, which makes this movie perhaps still somewhat disappointing to watch.

6/10

Watch trailer

Top