Style2

Meet Me in St. Louis (1944) Directed by Vincente Minnelli

-->



(Review originally written at 19 January 2009)

Within its genre this is simply a great movie to watch. It's a random slice of life that concentrates on a 'random' everyday family living in St. Louis, in the early 20th century. A real 'Americana' movie. It has all of the ingredients you could expect from a movie like this; drama, romance, comedy and basically everything in between.

But above all its a cheerful movie. After all it's a Vincente Minnelli musical, even though the movie is not filled with songs every 10 minutes. Nevertheless the songs that the movie does feature are magnificent and make the movie joyful to watch and gives it a lot of heart and color.

It's a great looking movie, that got shot completely in color. Early color movies from the '40's are often very bright because of their very vivid colors. It's doesn't always look too well by todays standards but in this particular case it works out greatly for the overall movie its feeling and atmosphere.

It's mostly a character driven movie, fore the story itself is of course quite formulaic for its genre but good and effective nevertheless, that has some nice themes in it, which get handled even better by the movie. The movie is filled with some great characters and the family gets portrayed nicely within the movie. It's a fine movie for Judy Garland, who looks great in this movie. It was the first movie she and director Vincente Minnelli did together. Shortly after finishing this movie they also got married together. I think its fair to say that their first movie was also the best one they did together, even though I haven't seen all of them yet.

There are a lot of musicals set in the same time period as this movie. I however feel that this movie in particular does a great job capturing the particular time period. with its costumes, sets, props settings, etcetera. It's a professional looking movie that got greatly put together, with some nice directing and editing. It's a well paced movie, which helps to make this a pleasant watch but not without being effective with its more dramatic themes as well.

Simply a great movie to watch!

9/10

Watch trailer

That Forsyte Woman (1949) Directed by Compton Bennett



(Review originally written at 18 July 2007)

The movie started off really well and interesting enough but about halve way through it suddenly starts to make some unbelievable twists, that are just not credible, which is mostly due to the acting.

Real problem is that it's highly unbelievable that Irene Forsyte (Greer Garson) and Philip Bosinney (Robert Young) fall in love in this movie, which is about the most essential part and twist in the story. Garson and Young have absolutely no chemistry together and how their are being drawn together by their love for each other is therefor highly unconvincing. On top of that Robert Young really doesn't have the right looks for the part, he was at least 10 years too old at the time for this role really.


A positive casting note was Errol Flynn in a serious and demanding role. He in this movie also shows that he could actually really act. It's also a rare movie in which he plays a more 'bad' than 'good' kind of character. He's perhaps the only real true highlight of the movie.


The still young Janet Leigh also appears in this movie in one of her first movie roles. Definitely not her best role, she still had a lot to learn but that's not just her fault. The script just didn't gave her that much interesting to do.


The movie is definitely more classy and better looking and made than the average MGM genre movie, made in the same period. It therefor is also perfectly watchable for persons who normally aren't too fond of the formulaic kind of '40's MGM period drama's.


The story still has some interesting elements and characters in it but its weaker and unconvincing second halve prevent this movie from being a true classic and above average one.


6/10

Top